Heather Isaacs

My initials spell "Hi."

Hi.

The Missionary Position, Part 1

The year between my sophomore and junior years of college, I worked as a student missionary. With my good friend Charity, we committed nine months to teaching English at a church-affiliated school in the city of Prague. As far as missionary positions go, ours was an easy job. Teach English during the week. Build relationships with students. Invite them to church. Basically, our task was to make the soft-sell for Jesus. This suited Charity and me just fine as we were not die-hard evangelist types by nature. We were, after all, English majors.

But like most teachers, we were overworked and underpaid. Our director, a tall thin woman with perfectly coiffed blonde hair once told us: “When you work for God you don’t need to eat or sleep like normal people.” Within the first week of arriving in Prague, we were already trying to prove to ourselves this was true. Perhaps for siddhas it is. But we needed to learn the hard way that as much as we loved Jesus, we still needed protein and sleep. Even our director was confronted with this lesson as we later learned she once collapsed in the shower from exhaustion.

Our cohort of five student missionaries were given the job of writing, re-writing, and editing textbooks for the school who wanted to avoid the cost of buying regular textbooks. All of the missionaries lived in panelaks–those ubiquitous Soviet-era cement-block apartment buildings that surround the ancient heart of Prague and extend toward the edges of the city like a cosmic game of dominoes. Whatever romance with Prague Charity and I hoped to find the moment we stepped onto the tarmac was temporarily shelved as we began the daily slog of traveling upwards of four hours by bus and metro between our apartment, the main school campus and other classes we taught in offices throughout the city. Our evening hours were spent rushing to write something polished enough to teach the next day to smart, savvy Czech students with plenty of other language study options to choose from in the city. We weren’t eating well or exercising. Under the stress of the year, I gained twenty pounds and grew a new beard of acne. (Unfortunately for me, dumplings are a staple of Czech cuisine and make for excellent comfort food.)

By mid-year, we could see how burnout was a likelihood for ourselves and we began doing more to prevent it and pushing back against our director’s expectations. In retrospect, I didn’t handle the situation with the maturest of conflict management skills. At the age of twenty, I still tended to use more dramatic, reactive means of protest to get my point across. Once, I made a display of choosing to go to bed over staying for a late-night mandatory textbook writing meeting that our director called right as I was crawling into bed. It was at least ten o’clock and none of the textbooks being discussed were levels I taught; I felt I wouldn’t have anything to offer to the discussion. I asked for permission to leave–I was so exhausted. But the director told me I had to stay. I left anyway and in doing so defied her direct order. This decision would come back to haunt me later.

But even as I write this I look back on that year and find it difficult to understand what was so hard about any of it. Inconvenient, yes. Full of hard work and homesickness, sure. A few power struggles with management, absolutely. But as far as missionary assignments go, we had a cushy one. We lived in one of the most beautiful cities on earth with amenities like running water, grocery stores, public transit, Joan Baez concerts, and weekend trips to places like Budapest and Krakow. Life in Prague was a cakewalk compared to stories I heard growing up of missionaries who served in truly dangerous times and places; a few who might as well have spent their time in the mission field traveling into the Heart of Darkness. We, by comparison, had nothing to complain about. Especially to our friendly neighborhood LDS missionaries  who once calmly told us a story of how they were chased away from an apartment door by a man with a shotgun.

As easy as the year should have been, I still got fired.

To date, I am the only person I know who has ever been fired from being a missionary.  I wasn’t even fired for ordinary offenses like being late to work one too many days in a row. Or embezzling church funds. Or having my own personal Thornbirds moment. Rather, I was accused of being an “agent of the devil” and having “lost souls for Christ” (although it was never explained to me how this number is counted). It just so happened that the night I abandoned the late-night meeting months earlier was the turning point, my director told me, in discovering the ugly, demonic truth of who I am at my core. It was only after that night when she began to “watch” me, she said, ultimately coming to the realization that she was the only person who knew me for who I really am. Everyone else I had manipulated and fooled. At the time, it was devastating to be accused of such things and it took years for me to recover. On the upside, I like to think of how much I was able to accomplish before I even turned 21. Agent of the devil is not a position you just get handed. You really have to earn it.

Of course, I wasn’t able to be so flip at the time. My director and I inhabited the same scary world of spiritual warfare–one in which Satan was real and powerful and salvation from his grip was tenuous and conditional.  I sometimes talked to Satan in my head like I was alerting a would-be attacker hiding in the dark that I was calling the police. And Satan was the reason for almost everything scary that I couldn’t explain, including the night Charity and I rode a nearly empty bus home during our first weeks in Prague and from somewhere behind us a man started talking loudly in Czech. I turned my head just far enough to see him out of the corner of my eye sitting in the very back, gesticulating with his hands. Not being able to understand a word he was saying, my mind began to run away with possible explanations for his seemingly frightening behavior. Mental illness crossed my mind, of course. Why else would someone talk to themselves at such a loud volume? But it also seemed entirely reasonable to me to guess that he was, in fact, possessed by the Devil. That would make sense, right? Here Charity and I were, just arrived in Prague to begin our missionary year and here was Satan attempting to scare us away from our purpose. Of course! I’d heard stories like this all the time at church. We were being tested. And I think I was failing the test because, to be honest, I was scared shitless. I wanted to turn to Charity for her assessment of the situation but I was afraid that would just draw the attention of the crazy, demon-possessed man closer to us. So I just stared straight ahead and prayed hard.

When the bus finally dropped us off in front of our apartment complex, I finally found my voice and asked what had been going through her mind during that terrifying bus ride. She looked at me quizzically and said, “You mean the man on the cell phone?”

Eight months later, I was fired for being an agent of the devil. There’s poetry in that, don’t you think?

Ultimately, however, due to advocacy from back home the director reversed her decision and let me stay on for the last month of my contract. The fact that I chose to stay on when your boss thinks you’re an agent of the devil now seems as crazy as believing someone is an agent of the devil and then letting them stay on at your school. Of course, she did require an apology for having raised my voice at her. During our ill-fated meeting, I remained tense but relatively calm even when it was clear from her opening prayer that I was screwed. (Word of advice: If you are ever in a meeting with someone who begins a prayer asking the Lord to help you know that everything she says is true, run.) At one point, I even asked her what I could do to improve my standing with her but her response seemed as weird to me in the moment as everything else. All she said was, “Say hi and bye like normal people!”  Eventually, it was clear there was nothing to do but leave. I offered to quit then got up to leave. But she said I couldn’t quit because she was firing me. Before I reached the door, she blocked my exit. It was then that I snapped and came face to face with my potential to do serious bodily harm to another human being. But instead of striking her with my fists, I started screaming at her, striking her with words, repeating over and over as I cried that she couldn’t do this to me which, of course, she could. And for the violence in my own response, I apologized.

But to her credit, she may have been onto something about the whole difficulty I have saying hi and bye like normal people. Maybe at the time I didn’t see the seed of truth in her observation about how I enter and leave rooms because I was too busy trying to absorb the whole agent of the devil thing. Apparently, I do have the habit of entering a room too quietly and standing in people’s blind spots. Creepy, I know. It’s not uncommon for me to startle someone upon entering a room. Recently,  I surprised a male colleague who jumped and said, “You keep scaring me!” I didn’t know what to say. So I said in a chipmunky, high- pitch tone, “I don’t know what that means!” And then I left. A response, I know, that only makes me seem more creepy and suggests I am, in fact, one of the Children of the Corn.

For certain, I don’t know when to leave a situation. Because somehow going home early that year from such a toxic environment never really entered my mind as a possibility. I couldn’t imagine returning home as a failed missionary and having to bear the disappointment and judgment of my community. But as I learned too late, there was only love waiting for me at home. The judgment and disappointment lived on in my own mind. And if it weren’t for my own stubborn pride, I would have spared myself a great deal of pain. I only wish I had the courage of another student missionary friend, a soft-spoken art major who took a position that same year in a remote part of Nepal only to discover that the resident missionaries there had set themselves up as the gentler, kinder versions of Kurz in the village. Believing the locals were “dirty,” the missionaries would not enter their homes. But they weren’t above using them to build a nice house for themselves up on the hill overlooking the village, either. Once this quiet artist missionary girl understood what was happening, she packed up her things and made the day-long hike back to the bus that would take her back to Kathmandu where she demanded a new assignment. I heard her tell this story and thought, “You mean you could do that? You could just leave?”

So by the time I did finally return home to California, I had only begun the long journey of leaving Prague. There’s a picture someone took as Charity and I stepped off the plane into the terminal at the San Francisco airport where a loving circle of our family and friends were waiting for us. In the picture, you can see me slightly falling forward, my arms stretched out reaching for my mom who was ready to catch me, my face contorted in pain and relief as I began to sob.  No one should return home from their missionary year crying like a sick cow. It’s bad for business. It frightens the public and it doesn’t translate well into a very marketable testimony. Most dangerous of all, it threatens the very heart of what a missionary is and does in the world—what does it say, after all, about the God you proclaim when you aren’t guaranteed the small benefit of returning home in your right mind.

And I wasn’t in my right mind. Though depression nipped at my heels for much of my adolescence, returning home from Prague threw me into one of the deepest depressions of my life. Always a serious student/athlete, I began finding myself doing things like sleeping much of the day, including through basketball practice. I lost my starting position on the team. I withdrew from friends. My dreams became a little too real, sometimes daring to cross into the realm of hallucinations. In the end, I decided to cut my junior year of college short and went home to my parents in the early Spring to try to find my new center of balance after having been thrown so far off course. It helped a little. But by my senior year of college, I still hadn’t found my center. One morning, as I lie awake in my dorm room bed, I had the very real experience of watching a lizard-faced demon dressed in a brown robe step out of my full-length mirror, turn, and look at me. The demon didn’t look at me with malice but with a sense of being lost–as though it didn’t know where it belonged either. I did my best to cast the demon out in the name of Christ. But it just stood there, looking at me, wondering what came next.


Discover more from Heather Isaacs

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

26 responses to “The Missionary Position, Part 1”

  1. I realize this question will make it seem like I completely missed the point, but I didn’t and thank you for your post! Do you not believe satan exists, and if not what do you believe in that regard? I don’t mean to interrogate, just want to understand clearly.

    1. Thanks for your comment. I don’t think the point of my article was about whether or not Satan exists but it’s true that I have changed in regard to what I believe about Satan. I don’t hold a literal, personified view of Satan anymore. And I’m not sure whether it matters to me exactly what we believe if at the end of the day if we are still fighting internal demons. My healing continues to come from turning towards the love and light that I keep finding in my life and for that I am grateful to God.

  2. Lindsey Painter Avatar
    Lindsey Painter

    I just want you to know something. I was going to be a student missionary in Prague. I had already filled out the paperwork and everything. But then someone told me about you and I decided against it. I had the most wonderful year 2003-2004 in Pohnpei Micronesia. I’m sorry you had to go through that. I have always wondered about you and how you are doing now. I’m glad I stumbled on this blog!

    1. Wow! That’s really crazy! But I’m so glad to hear you had an amazing time in Pohnpei. I remember that it seemed how almost everyone who came back from Pohnpei had wonderful things to say about their experience. I still recommend going to Prague one day just to visit though. It’s such a beautiful city. Thanks for saying hello!

  3. I taught English in Kazakhstan and understand so so well what you are talking about. I had some serious conflicts with our director and while I didn’t get fired, my husband who worked with David Gates in South America the year before we met did get sent home early for a false accusation. That’s a crazy story too. I’m so glad you had the courage to write about what happened. Every time I get a chance I talk to church leadership about the abusive attitudes, lack of proper oversight, and dangerous conditions that exist in the Student Missionary program.

  4. Absolutely riveting writing–and I’ve even heard this story before. Thank you so much for sharing. I am eagerly awaiting part II!

  5. I think abuse/mistreatment of student missionaries happens far, far more than people suspect. Thanks for sharing your story.

  6. The Church is full of abusive power mad people. I experienced it as a teenager and young person. When I was a theology student at Avondale College some of the people in my prayer group went to a Pentecostal Church and apparently got filled with the Spirit. I wasn’t there didn’t even know about it. But because I was in the prayer group I got hauled up before the Theological board to ‘please explain’. Explain what was my response. Undaunted by the truth; the College Church Pastor rang my then girlfriends parents (who were Missionaries in New Guinea) and told them I was possessed by the Devil. I stress, I did nothing to justify these false allegations. It didn’t matter. Powerless I stood and watched my future as a worker for the Church go gurgling down the drain. I went into a massive decline and depression which ultimately saw me flunk out of College. I was suicidal. I am sure my mental illness served to prove how correct that Pastor was in his assessment that I was devil possessed. He spread gossip but never lifted a finger to offer help. The damage inflicted took years to recover from. Ironically, this mistreatment eventually sent me to work for Teen Challenge, a Drug Rehabilitation Center run by The Assembly of God. There I learned about the Holy Spirit and the difference between demon possession, mental illness and drug induced psychosis.

  7. I had a similar experience, as a pastor who was fired from denominational employment. The details, geography, and circumstances were all vastly different – but the situation and social politics were very similar.

    It’s terrible to see a few spiritually abusive people reeking so much havoc. I so wish, we would show a little more tough love on these abusers and perpetrators. The spiritually abusive are no less a threat than those who abuse with violence, sex, or bullying.

    I’m so sorry for your experience.

    I tell people, at least they didn’t stone me or nail me to a cross. However, putting my wife and children at risk was a terrible thing to watch.

  8. I was a student missionary to Egypt. Easily the worst year of my life. I thought I was going to die there. SMs get treated terribly.

  9. That is sad that you were treated so poorly.

  10. Wow, I could have written this. I was in Prague from 1999-2000 as an SDA missionary – so I am pretty sure we were at the same school. Terrible, life-altering experience. Grateful that I found God again, but I was in a pretty dark place for a while afterwards. I’m so sorry we both had to go through that.

    1. That makes me really sad to hear. I was there in ’97-’98 so my guess is that it was the same school. Hard for me to believe colleges kept sending their student missionaries there. I’m glad we both got through it. For years, I was so angry. But now, the experience has become a part of me in a way that I am at peace with. Maybe it’s why I can finally write about this now. I can hear that you’ve found healing, too. It’s affirming to hear that our experiences weren’t anomalous. It was so crazy-making at times that I had to question myself if it was really happening. I totally understand how life-altering it could be.

      1. No, you are definitely not an anomaly. Unfortunately, this is not the first time I’ve heard horror stories from this particular mission field. 😦

  11. Your story seems tragic to me. I, too, was a student missionary. I went to Korea in the early 80s. We were treated very well, We taught 6 classes a day and spent the rest of our time touring and going to museums and tea houses, orchards, shopping centers, or universities with students, who were university students, housewives, businessmen, 5-star generals, neurosurgeons, and all other types of people. There were some SMs who left because they were homesick or the teaching wasn’t what they thought it would be. Our director tried to help anyone in any way. We were paid enough to purchase clothes, food, and gifts to send home. I always had extra money left. Our apartment was upstairs from the classroom. If I didn’t have a family and job now, I would love to go back! My friends went to Costa Rica, Indonesia, Palau, Guam, and Japan, and every one of them claimed to have loved it. I wish your parents had “turned in” the abusive director. Nobody should have to suffer what you did.

  12. I was at that same school form ’99 – ’01. Yes, two years. (Why, I still don’t know–I must have been especially dense or blind–a glutton for punishment–because it took me awhile to recognize the true colors.) I’m so sorry for your experience, and ultimately, my experience was very, very similar. It was life-changing, but probably not in the way student missionary programs are meant to be. After depression, confusion, etc, I successfully, and happily, have found a wonderful life outside of the church.

    I’ve always thought that someone should write about book about this, and I’ve made attempts but I still can’t get my mind around it. It’s too large, too crazy. Maybe a compilation of essays from all of us who have been through it?

    1. Wow, you’re the second person to reply with a similar story. But you were there for two years!! Wow. I can’t believe that our schools kept sending student missionaries even with all that was happening! I was there in ’97-’98 and I wasn’t able to write about this for years. Until now, really. I felt so much shame and anger for such a long time. When I posted it on Facebook yesterday, I actually said something very similar to what you wrote. The experience was so big, so strange, so painful that it took time to get the kind of distance that would allow me to re-visit it. If/when it is the right time for you to write your story, I’d be very interested to read it.

      1. Sometimes I wonder if part of the difficulty of understanding the experience is when it happened in our lives–the early 20s are a crucial time, and in my case, anyway, I was a babe in the woods, wonderfully naive about how the world worked and thoroughly indoctrinated in certain tenants. Being away from home, beginning to reevaluate one’s place in the world and the very root of one’s beliefs is tough enough–suffering at the hands of a profoundly unhappy/troubled person is icing on the cake. There is a rich vein of story-making material here to be tapped! 🙂

        The story of the man on the cell phone really struck me–a vivid example of how our mindsets can inform our perceptions. So interesting.

      2. I so agree, Rachelle. Young, naive, committed. We were so in over our heads. This is from a poem I wrote about that year soon after I got back:

        “Nine months of labor only to
        miscarry myself home
        broke-down,
        a woman junked in her first attempt.”

        And I just checked out your blog! I’m in Napa, too!

  13. Such a sad experience in the guise of religion. Several months ago I read the book “When Religion Becomes Evil” and your story is only one of many true examples. Nothing can be worse than to be under the symbolic “protection” of the church to be so abused. You have a wonderful gift of writing and this story should be much more widely spread as a warning to young, naive students who only wish to serve others, but become servants of a slaveholder.

  14. I came to Prague in 1991, but arrived in the city completely separated from SDA-ism. I was going thru my own trauma, determined to **do something different with my life** .
    I came to teach English, but I came knowing several Czechs who were returning home after living in the USA. So my experience was different.
    During my first month here, I met that director, I knew that she was not the type of person that I would choose to hang around. I appreciated the fact that she translated the sermons during church service, but …
    I used to breeze by the church/school on Sabbaths on occasion. I went there more frequently 2008 until they stopped importing teachers from the USA. (you might know that she HAD to stop… student and parents complained about the un-needed religious they were getting … if they want THAT, they would have gone to a Catholic school… so went the complaint)
    I’m still here, more than 20 years, now… still teaching English, still having the time of my life, finally, now that I’ve got gray hair!!
    Best wishes to you in all that you do, from now on…

    Clever name… the missionary position
    –Lee Andrew

    1. Ah, I so envy that you were able to be in Prague so soon after the Velvet Revolution! Thank you for your reflection. All the best to you, as well!

  15. Thank you for bravely sharing your story Heather. I was also a SM. It wasn’t a good situation and I left early, which deeply disappointed my family. The experience and shame of disapproval festered in me resulting in self-loathing, depression and suicidal thoughts. I remember hearing that a large percentage of SM’s leave the church and it made sense after I came back. It is frightening to be a naïve idealist and see the inner-workings of the church and find that things just don’t match up. The difficulty with such an experience is that it isn’t OK to talk about it. Everyone wants a good missionary story, not the sad truth. I remember sitting on a panel sending off a new SM thinking, “DON’T do it!!” while feeling like I had no other choice but to say out loud, “It was a memorable experience.” Twelve years later I admittedly still have pain to process from the ordeal. At my lowest points I saw Grace face-to-face. When all others forsook me, He took me up. That is the Beauty I have found in these ashes.

  16. jeanettebrantley Avatar
    jeanettebrantley

    Wow… I can tell you that you weren’t the first student missionary to get fired. I think I held that honor after a year teaching elementary school in Sierra Leone, West Africa that destroyed me for decades. I have tried to write the story ever since I returned in 1971 but each time I have tried it brought up all of the trauma as though it was happening afresh. I began attempting to write it all in earnest back in 2007, as Lee Andrew Davison can attest. I promised him he could read the first chapter but I have been stuck on the first few pages of that first chapter even now!

    Reading Part 1 of your story and the comments, as well, it is obvious that many young people were scarred by a program that was supposed to enrich the lives of both the students and those in the mission field.

    Each one of us needs to tell our story; to dispel the shadowy film of lies with the sharp light of our truth. That is how change will happen.

  17. Thank you everybody for sharing your own stories. I’m gratefully overwhelmed by all the comments. Reading them is bringing me deep healing to hidden layers of fear and shame that I was still carrying about this time in my life. I still felt some fear of inviting recrimination and judgment in talking about it. But because of this experience, I am deeply moved by the realization that though our personal stories are uniquely our own that they are also part of a collective experience and that healing and transformation arise naturally when we simply share our stories and remember we aren’t alone. I’m sorry there are so many of us with soul-shattering stories of being student missionaries. I wonder about the causes of this troubling phenomenon and why it’s repeated over and over again.

Leave a reply to Gary Walter Cancel reply